New to listening. Looking forward to the back half of season 3 - my favorite episodes of the series! Have enjoyed this take on season 1 so far. I like how you summarize what happens in the scenes before talking about them. Keep going!

I found this podcast about 3 weeks ago and binged the entire thing since then! I love your fresh perspectives to the show and enjoy listening to you go through it for the first time. I hope you guys get to go through the entire series but if not I’ve had a lovely time on the journey with you so far.

Loved Dawson’s Creek growing up and recently started rewatching it. Looked up something on Reddit about it and people were suggesting this podcast. I immediately tuned in and have been hooked ever since! I’ve been listening to it non-stop while I’m working. Love your takes and perspective on things I would’ve never thought of. You guys are seriously funny! I’ve laughed out loud more times than I can count. Can’t wait to keep listening! Great job guys! 🙂

Recently decided to watch a couple of episodes of Dawson’s Creek, for the nostalgia factor. Got hooked and have been binging for weeks now. Realized around middle of season 2 that I never really watched past that point in the 90’s, so I’m watching it with a fresh perspective too! Then went searching for a rewatch podcast, but found yours instead…and so glad I did. I’m up to early season 5 now and am very impatiently waiting for you guys to catch up. I have developed a love/hate relationship with the show and I find myself during every episode saying to myself, “I can’t wait to hear what the Freaks & Creeks gang thinks about this storyline/nonsense/absurdity.” You guys are in for a wild ride. Keep up the good work!

I’ve been listening from the beginning! I don’t always agree with their takes but that’s what makes it fun. They are very thoughtful and thorough in their analysis of the episode. Their discussion is below the surface and that feels refreshing.

Love this podcast. It’s a great way to revisit one of my favorite series of all time. I really enjoy hearing your takes and can’t wait for you to dive deep into season three— easily the season filled with the most iconic moments of the series. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! 🩷

Was listening to Homecoming…y’all have NO idea how much of an impact ice cream will have on this show! Anyways, love the Podcast!! ♥️

From top to bottom you guys are funny, smart and provide great insight! I love the recaps and the recommendations. I wish it was out weekly! 🛶 when this is done, I could see your next endeavor being the original 90210. That show has a lot to unpack and equally as entertaining!

...2 long weeks between each episode -- I want to listen to these freaks all day. I don't wanna wait -- To laugh about my teen obsession. These 4 hosts are equal parts intelligent -- and fuuuuunny. Doo doo doo do do. Doo doo doo do do. Doo doo doo do doooooo. 🛶

You guys are great! I’m making my way through as many Dawson’s Creek podcasts as I can in preparation for doing my own. Y’all are by far one of my favorites!

This is my first time leaving a review for this podcast, but I wanted to say how much I loved your review of Reunited. The conversation about Andie’s breakdown and hallucinations was fantastic. This was my favorite episode yet.

I just found your podcast a while ago and personally love to hear the deep analysis that goes on and your interesting view points. I'm glad I found you guys while youre so early into the show, I'm ready to go along for the ride! Wasn't a big fan of the pacey hate in the beginning but I’m happy you guys eventually got it! This podcast is really enjoyable and so SO funny (that’s right 2 of them), I can't wait for more! Here's to the future, and the hope that you guys can make sense of the reason they act like /that/ in the college seasons. But until then, keep doing what you're doing! <3

Hello! I am a pretty late to the party but I am thrilled to have found you. I listen to an unusually large amount of 90s rewatch podcasts. I appreciate your unfiltered and brutally honest assessments! It’s so fun and refreshing! I am a later born Gen X-er who watched when the show originally aired and have rewatched so many times I couldn’t count. I have a love/hate relationship with Dawson’s Creek but it is forever the place where I met one of my most long-lasting teenage mediated boyfriends. Growing up in love with Dylan McKay, Pacey Whitter, and Luke Danes (in that order)… I am grateful to hear you slowly coming around to the rogue charm of Pacey! So many good times to come! Thank you for bringing joy into my little world! Much love and support, Candice

I’ve been following along since your first show and I love listening to your unbiased takes on the best show from my teenage years. I watched Dawson’s Creek when it first aired in the 90s, re-watched when it was featured on Netflix a few years ago, and started watching a third time when I discovered your podcast (although, it’s not on Max anymore so I’m a little lost)! DC is definitely one of my all-time favorite shows and hearing your thoughts as grown adults is fun! Your banter is entertaining and I especially love Cody’s enthusiastic rundown of the show’s summary at the start of each episode. Keep it up and good luck with sponsorship!

Been a fan of this show since the original run. I don't always agree with your opinions, but I enjoy the fresh perspective untainted by the shipping wars. I'm kind of worried that I'm almost caught up to your most recent episode though, so I hope you continue to put out new content. You are about to enter what for most fans is considered Peak Creek.

Love rewatching this show and listening to your discussions, they are really a great mix of enjoyment and critique!! This show was on when I was in high school but it wasn’t until college that I really watched it with my favorite roommates/best friends so it brings back very fond memories. Glad you are back from the break because I need great entertainment while I work :)

I was apprehensive to listen to this podcast because I have such a protective love for Dawson’s Creek, but I was so relieved to hear these voices bring in a new perspective to something they’ve never seen, and are viewing for the first time as adults. They have brought up so many points that I thought of when I was first watching this as a 13-yr old, but also so many more that I never noticed because of my youth and naivety; it’s refreshing and funny and relatable! Also, I’m relieved they’ve gotten into season 2 and aren’t hating on Pacey as much. 🤗 This podcast is fresh and fun and I’m enjoying the heck out of it!

I love listening to this first time perspective on the show while currently rewatching the show on my own. It's great to hear the hosts discovering all the things I have loved about the show for so long, as well as bringing new opinions and theories including all these vampires in Capeside. I only wish I had found you later so I wouldn't be almost caught up with episodes already!

I’ve listened to every Dawson’s Creek podcast available, and this is my favorite so far. I like how all four podcasters bring something different to the table. They all have great “radio” voices too — no small thing when you’re using AirPods. The podcast is just super enjoyable, and makes my long commute bearable. One more thing: The screenplay under “about” on the website cracked me up! I teach screenwriting, and I’m always hoping one of my students will crank out a silly parody. A+

As an OG Gen-X fan who has watched this series at least a dozen times (don’t judge me) and is fully immersed in the fandom, the podcast is amazing. Listening to the perspective of millennial virgin listeners who are insightful, smart, and funny is so great. And I love this show still speaks to an audience two plus decades later. I have consumed so much DC content, and yet this podcast has been able to surprise me with different takes and opinions in things I’ve never heard before. And as a veteran watcher, hearing the predictions are also extremely entertaining. I have recommended this pod to everyone I know in the fandom. As some of the “big” DC podcasts are entering later seasons, this is THE podcast to listen to.

I didn’t need to watch Dawson’s creek. I didn’t especially want to watch Dawson’s creek. But now I look forward to watching an episode every dang week so I can tune in. Who have I become?

LOVE these hosts. It feels like I’m listening to four friends talk about a terribly entertaining show from the 90’s. Very lovable, painfully fun. #CapesideVampiresExist

Like the deep dives and humor - hope you like Pacey eventually- it’s really difficult with his current story - but also that’s totally on the adult - this is abuse after all - so it feels weird to hate him so much in that context -

Even if you don’t give two hoots about Dawson’s Creek, these four hosts are so funny to listen to. I love when they point out weird plot points (in what world do teens row up to each other’s houses to hang??) Makes you feel like you’re having a convo with them. The long episodes are great for drives to/from work, and I want to be able to binge but it’s so fresh! Excited for more eps!

Hilarious group of folx talking about a seminal piece of pop culture. Excited for more!

The nostalgia, the banter, the laughs! Keep these coming please!