I love watching Gilmore girls, and the podcast is fun sometimes because I like learning about different scenes, background, etc.… But Scott Patterson is one of the most annoying people on the planet. I love the pop culture. It’s so much fun, and honestly, I like the other two ladies who try in but Scott’s insistence on him being correct about everything is so obnoxious nearly ruins it for me. But I come back for the pop culture.

Loudest, most obnoxious opening and closing music of any podcast which bookends - a ton of grating ads. Meh content. The sound engineer is better prepared for interviews than the rest of the cohort.

Nobody: Amy talks Me: skip button>>

I hate how much I hate Scott's opinions on everything. 🤦🏻‍♀️

My fellow Gilmore fans, please don’t listen to this podcast. Listen to Gilmore Guys, instead. Really. 1) Scott is really not who you want Luke to be… for example, he is obsessed with defending known abusers like Depp and Pitt. 2) They completely rip off a podcast started by two young men SEVEN years earlier. Like, he stole the bits/segments/ideas/etc. and he can’t feign not knowing about it. He was on the show within months of its premiere. 3) It is so so so much less funny than Gilmore Guys. 4) I don’t want to write spoilers for either podcast, but Kelly Bishop appears on Gilmore Guys in their first few months and hasn’t been on I Am All In after all of these years. That’s just an example. 5) 60% of more of I Am All In is advertisements on already short episodes, while Gilmore Guys has like 2 mins of ads in 90 min eps. Truly, if you love Gilmore Girls, do not listen to those podcast. If you haven’t listened to Gilmore Guys, you will thank me!!

Loved listening to Scott’s recaps of course, but have also been delighted by producer Easton’s interviews! Really fun and I’ve learned a lot about all the obscure references in GG.

I love Gilmore girls so much. It is amazing and it was like the first show. You know that was kind of mature for me and I just really really loved that I went to Outer Banks. You know what I want to young Sheldon and a good girls guide to murder Gilmore girls is always the stuff it’s so amazing and Scott your podcast is just show like awesome and amazing. Love you, Scott!

Please let your guests and co-podcasters talk. I appreciate Scott’s opinions and insights, but let the others fully express their thoughts and answer the questions you ask them instead of keep talking.

I am a Luke Danes kind of guy. My wife got me into Gilmore Girls after we got married about 2 years ago. Since then I’ve seen every episode and season in full 3 times. It’s gets better and better! I have recently been to the WB set and I have called the streets of Stars Hallow. This podcast feels like Stars Hallow is hometown and that Luke Danes is an old buddy I can catch up with. My wife and I LOVE the pop culture reference section. Suggestion: bring back “Jess” to the podcast more. That collaboration is always great!

I adore Danielle & Amy’s podcasts. I could listen to them chat about almost anything. I’m looking forward to the Parenthood podcast.

PLEASE NO ADS THAT REFERENCE ANAL OR ORAL SEX. I have listened to every episode of this podcast, and lately they are including an ad plugging an iheart podcast, I think called hookups? It’s clearly going to contain gay sexual references and allusions HEAVILY because the ad itself has two. I can’t opt out of listening to this ad, which means this podcast is no longer safe for consumption with a wide audience.

I like the episodes with Suzanne and Danielle, but the others are meh. Unsubscribing due to the obscene number of ads

Love it all. Almost always in line with Danielle’s opinions. Just wish they’d all let each other finish thoughts. So many interruptions. I excuse it because I know everyone is just so passionate about GG!

I really like Easton’s interviews I learn a lot

Easton’s pop cult is the best part of the show. His joy is so obvious as he interviews!!! Keep it up

I don’t think Scott can separate himself from Luke and he just becomes insufferable. He can’t hear any other perspective and it’s Uber. Annoying as somebody who has watched the entire series 20 times him have these strong takes on how things would play out when he hasn’t even watched the show.Good glad you filmed it, but you weren’t aware if you’re telling the truth, how pieces were clipped together and how things played out. He’s just coming across as bitter and awful and is often uninformed. Was he on the show, yes. Did he watch the show and fully understand the characters in their evolution, I say no. There are many things that he says that Luke would do that Luke did not do through the when they get to reviewing a year in the life. That’s where I just can’t tolerate him at all. This podcast is terrible and sometimes you can be too close to to see it for what it is and the way he treats his cohost that disagree with him is disgusting. Now I hate Luke and I want. Laura lie to leave him procreate with him. As Taylor said, “I think you were born a bitter and surly killjoy.”

I have been a Gilmore Girls Fan for 5+ years & I wish I knew this podcast existed sooner & kind of upset with myself that I just discovered it…

I really want to enjoy this podcast but the constant ranting and talking over each other has made it impossible to listen to.

All the audio skips distract me more than the reviews are able to hold my interest…what the heck?

I love the town meeting!! Suzanne and Tara are awesome. Scott is kind of a downer but I like the again with the cast/directors!!! Watch out for the news with Danielle and Amy. They spoil other shows without warning and just ruined “this is us” for me. (Yes I know it’s been out since 2022 but that’s still new in streaming world.)

I am loving the new format! Pop culture, what’s new with the crew, and the again episode review with special guests is incredible! Keep it up!

This podcast has been great until season 7, when all they seem to do is trash the show.

I have been listening to and enjoying this show for years but since they started the Netflix movie reviews they have double down on ads and it has made the show unbearable to listen to. Ever 5 minutes there are 2-3 minutes of ads and it’s infuriating- starting with ads, 5 minutes in ads, 10 minutes in ads. The show isn’t worth listening to THAT many ads. Way to squeeze every last penny out of the last two episodes.

…Again? I can’t imagine the point in re-doing the podcast from the beginning except as some sort of money-grab which feels really lame. I started this podcast from the very beginning because I was excited to hear Scott’s perspective and also the perspective of someone watching it for the first time, and at a certain point I just felt too far in to stop. But I don’t find much of the episodes very interesting and I find myself tuning out of a lot of it. Idk. I listen to a lot of podcasts every week and this is the most skipped one in my library by far, especially the pop culture and other bonus content.

Since Scott seems to know so much more than the Palladino’s……just asking. 🤣

I love this podcast! I love listening to the episode and then rewatching the episode afterwards to catch all the little things they talked about. It’s so funny and love hearing everyone’s POV! Also, Suzanne was a such a fun add and she’s my new fav…love all her Easter eggs and opinions.

I watch Gilmore girls everyday. Even being a huge GG fan, I can’t stand this podcast. I took a 2 year break hoping it would get better, it hasn’t. If it weren’t for the occasional interesting factoid, I would stop.

I enjoy this podcast. It is the only Gilmore Girls podcast I have been able to get into. I look forward to listening each week. To me, it feels more like I am overhearing a conversation from a group of friends. It is pretty informal and some friends talk more than others. I don’t always agree with what they say, and they don’t always agree with each other but that makes it fun. I love Gilmore Girls and have seen it several times but I don’t take it super seriously so I am ok with hearing lots of varying opinions and rolling my eyes when they get details wrong or don’t remember things. I usually skip pop culture and the one on ones.

Thank you for your time and dedication to the show and bringing the fans content! I loved hearing how Scott fell in love with the show as he started watching it for the first time and seeing how this developed over time. What they provide here is unique. It’s great to get different perspectives and opinions, hear about pop culture, acting and behind the scenes reality. I think too many people are listening hoping to hear what they want to hear and aren’t open to the interesting and maybe unexpected discussions provided. This may not be for everyone, but I appreciate the candid feelings and thoughts of this group and their guests. I’m having a great time!

This wouldn’t be so bad if Amy wasn’t there. Can’t stand her. Talking over everyone, doing annoying things like eating on air and going on rants completely off topic, trying to force everyone to agree with her stupid and ridiculous opinions. She seems to want to talk about how her hair looks and what she’s wearing instead of Gilmore Girls. And she’s constantly spoiling the show for Scott and Danielle, who are watching it for the first time, even though they’ve told her over and over again not to. She is the worst part of this podcast, and it would be so much better without her. Scott is ok, but I get the impression he thinks he’s god’s gift to man. Love Danielle, Suzanne, and Tara. Gilmore Girls is my favorite show, and I’ve already listened to the entirety of Gilmore Guys, which was hilarious perfection.

I love looking back, but the constant interrupting is annoying and takes away from the show. Scott becomes rude and irritating when no one agrees with his opinion.

I either LOVE or HATE listen. No in between. Pop Culture is always a skip for me so I hate when it’s a Monday episode. :(

It’s just gets worse and worse. Scott Patterson comes across as a spoiled brat that never grew up. I used to love the character of Luke….listening to him on this podcast has ruined Luke for me.

Its so weird they never have either of the stars on scotts awesome but come on

I used to listen to this podcast back in season one but had to stop because of how many times I couldn’t understand how little the people talking really understand the characters in the show. I really want to agree more with Scott, but I don’t think he understands the characters that live in stars hollow. Especially Lorelei. I’m surprised that he seems to have such a love for Lorelei as Scott through Luke, but simultaneously thinks that she’s just a rich snob a lot of the time. I decided to listen to the latest episode today to see if anything had changed in the format because there used to be segments that felt really off-topic and we’re honestly just boring to listen to. And I still feel like the podcast cast doesn’t understand the story or the characters in the show. Scott seems truly upset to hear that Gilmore girls is about Lorelei. He even said “well I don’t have any more opinions. You guys have fun talking because I’m just flotsam.” that’s not at all what’s being said. How do you not know that the show is about Lorelei? It doesn’t negate the work that Scott has done nor the character of Luke. Is it disappointing that Rory is a disappointment? Yes. Is it off character for her? Absolutely not. Many many times throughout the original series we have seen where Rory doesn’t have the gumption that Lorelei has. Do the movies live up to the original? No. And a lot of the things you guys said about using certain characters as clowns is true. But it’s crazy to me that Scott doesn’t seem to understand that the very thing he was talking about – having a storyline and it not being boring is what the writers were doing. If everyone is thriving, which of course we all want to see by the end of these movies, then what is the storyline? There’s no obstacle to overcome. Did they do some of the characters dirty? Absolutely. But some of those characters really do make sense if you look at it from a life and character development stance. We don’t always get to know the backstory of everyone. That’s what’s cool about watching a show. We don’t always understand the motivation. I think they were trying to show us the motivation through these movies. I also agree with (I think it’s Amy) saying that she sees herself in Lorelei. Saying that women her age are going through those things. You have to remember, the audience has grown up too. Those of us that originally watched Gilmore girls are now adults. Even though I’m younger, I’ve always seen myself in Lorelei. Gilmore girls has always had a lot of whimsy, and that is what brings us back to it all the time, but it also has always had relationships and issues that speak to a more realistic level.If we look at Gilmore girls on a whole, their whole lives and think about character development and the way we want to see them grow, the movies are just one Point in that life. So if they did another movie that was another 10 years in the future we want to see development from where they are. But I think the writer of the show had said she wanted to show us what would happen if everything went wrong instead of everything going right. We wouldn’t believe it if the storyline of everyone was perfect.

Throughout the podcast episodes I have found Amy usually insufferably grating. After listening to the Winter installments, I finally had to comment. Amy needs voice lessons, first of all, as her voice is too high pitched and very annoying when she gets excited and starts talking over everyone, which happens often. As a radio professional, hasn't anyone ever pointed this out to her? The tone of her voice often is like chalk on a board! Secondly, Amy's role should be to facilitate the conversation and Scott's inputs and perspectives, not talk over him, again and again, and when she disagrees with what he says, why does has to continue to talk over him and discount his opinion telling him he's wrong... Maybe just maybe, she is? And in this last episide she was like a dog with a bone, and had to have the last word, coming back with her same disagreeing points over and over to the point of ridiculously annoying exhaustion. I honestly think Amy is better suited in an off the air role.

True rating: 2 1/2. Because there so many people talking all the time about nothing! Why?! It should be Scott and maybe one other co-host. And yes, invite another person from time to time. But…too many voices - and Amy is just grating my nerves. Take a big breath, Amy, because you’re really starting to bug me. And to everyone, stop going off on tangents. Stop talking over each other. Stop rambling about each others personal lives. It’s unnecessary, and it’s irritating. So you might ask, why do I still listen? Because I love Gilmore Girls. I like the behind-the-scenes. I like the genuine discussions about the trajectory & dialogue of the characters. I like Scott Patterson. Overall, it’s more satisfying than annoying. But, this ok podcast could be a great podcast with a little bit more editing and restraint. I know the “skip 30 seconds ahead” button well, even though the subject matter is near and dear to my heart.

More Scott, love Scott and his perspectives! I almost always agree with your take on the situations (like Luke’s denigration as a character in Winter). Love the show and everyone’s take and back and fort, HOWEVER Amy needs to learn to listen more and interrupt less. It’s not the Amy show. I know you’re all friends, however, Scott I see you and I validate your points. Sometimes it feels like your take gets bulldozed over.

I’ve been listening for well over a year and love hearing Scott’s take and the discussions had by the crew, but for the first time I had to turn it off on this last winter episode because of Amy arguing with Scott over the stupid chair!! I just couldn’t take it anymore! If someone has a different opinion then her she has to talk them into submission and have the last word! It’s so disrespectful. I was cringing for Scott. If anything it should be his opinion that’s expressed the most! He was there, he held the script, acted the scenes! Lets be honest the fans are all here to hear him.

I’m late to the game. Almost 50 years of age I was very busy in 2000-2007 never watched Gilmore. Until my daughter got to be Rory’s age in the show. (Cue waterworks) LOVE IT! (Told my mom to watch too) I am rewatching with this podcast and connect the most with Amy and Scott (cause I’m old too). Love the pop culture references explained. But mostly Scott’s “master class” in acting for film and television is fascinating.

So you have to be man enough to admit you are wrong. I admit that I misinterpreted or misheard something and took it to me something completely different. This age of cyber stocking and cyber bullying takes a toll on a person psych. I take back everything I said in my last review, honestly, none of it had nothing to do with you guys. It wasn’t your fault and it was all on me. Again, my sincerest apologies. The addition of Suzanne has been very great. It’s been great to have some in intellectual expansion to these reviews. I enjoy the tangents and the rants. I also didn’t hate episode seven as much as other people did. Season seven excuse me. I actually think Lucy and Olivia aside from Paris were the best friends that Rory ever had. I think April was great addition to the show because she helped Luke grow and it was evident by just watching the episodes. You see Logan mature and actually become more than just a spoiled rich kid. there were other things that I can’t think of right now. Sometimes you would like to hear more insight from Scott having been a part of the show but overall the show just got better and better as it went on. And honestly, if you guys decided to watch the entire show from seasons one through seven all over again, I would be totally down with it. and I sincerely apologize for calling Amy old. I love you all and you have a part of the safe space that Gilmore girls has been for me for many many years now. Please don’t stop doing what you were doing and again sorry for my misinterpretations of what I heard and mistook to mean something that honestly didn’t mean what I thought it meant. You guys keep doing your thing.

A bit long, they babble a lot and get off topic but i like it. also, babette ate oatmeal!

I was so excited for this podcast but I cannot listen without being irritated because Amy will not stop talking and speaking over people. I’d give it a 4/5 without her.

I have been looking for Stars Hollow in my road trip wanderings. I love Scott’s humor, I can listen to him talk for ever. The fact that he is telling us all about one of my most favorite things in the world???? AWESOME!!!! I love this podcast. Im not sure why he discusses with really young people that don’t get 90% of the references. That’s kind of irritating. Maybe an “older” person thrown in would be better. 3/12/22 Second addendum: I can’t listen to this Podcast any more. If it was just Scott it would be ok. Was so glad pop culture is separate so I can skip it. This is no longer entertaining. 8/21/24 I come back and TRY SO MANY times to listen to this podcast as I watch GG DVDs at least once a year and would love more insight that this podcast used to give in the beginning. Behind the scenes stuff etc. But the further into the seasons of this podcast there is no longer any behind the scenes info, it’s just basic BORING OPINIONS, and I literally cannot just cannot listen to Amy. Yeah she says she cant help butting in but gezuz. ALL THE TIME????? she talks over everyone, doesn’t let anyone talk. And it’s just her opinions that she butts in with. WHO CARES????oh and I noticed she will be against something and then someone else says something and she quickly agrees which is opposite. No credibility to the buttinski. This was my 4th or 5th time trying??? I just cant. Too bad.

I can’t take the whining and the over the top childish reactions here. Fine to criticize the writing and the story arc of season seven, but can you try to converse like adults? I had to turn off the latest podcast episode before it was over. Have to add there are way too many ads on this podcast. I’ll finish this one out, but I’ll never follow another iheart podcast, there so much better content out there without ads.

I love this podcast because I’m obsessed with Gilmore girls and it’s so fun. My biggest dream is to meet the cast of Gilmore girls. Especially Scott Patterson and Lauren Graham. I LOVE LAUREN GRAHAM!!! Y'all did so good playing your characters in Gilmore girls.

If you can’t stop yawning thru the podcast pls pick another time to record. One person just kept obnoxiously yawning.

Yall never seem to understand that your “bone to pick” is a peek into the inner workings of the character, not just how they present themselves on the outside. These moments that feel off often lead to bigger moments in later episodes. Cool it. Also, yall have more ads than any other podcast I listen too.

I have been watching and rewatching since the pilot was launched on tv..This is my go to show it’s my background noise. I feel very happy when I watch it. When I first discovered the podcast, I rewatched Gilmore every week. I love how each episode is dissected and when you guys point out the Easter eggs which I’ll be watching again. I was able to finally take the WB Tour and I absolutely loved it. I saw Mrs Kim’s home, sookies house, starshollow high. Rory’s study tree and of course the gazebo where I got to take a picture sitting on the steps. Just loved it. Thank you all for doing this podcast, I look forward to it each week.

I just started rewatching Gilmore Girls for the 3rd time and found this podcast so I'm watching along with the podcast. I'm loving it! I wish I was up to date so I could maybe be called into the episodes like they are doing in Season 1, so I may have to skip ahead because I see they are currently almost at the end of Season 7. I love listening to Scott's reactions to watching this for the first time. I love his opinions as both Scott and Luke. I also love all the pop culture references. I thought I got most of them all but after listening to them recap them, I do miss some so it's great to learn these things. Very interesting and enjoyable. Looking forward to rewatching while listening to this podcast at the same time.