True Crime Garage

31,674

Hosts Nic and the Captain invite you to grab a chair, grab a beer and join them as they talk some true crime. This is no ordinary garage: it’s a rabbit hole of true crime, with a generous supply of alcohol and banter to lighten the load. From international atrocities to heinous stories on (US) home turf, dive head-first into a different case each week, and enjoy a cold one whilst your there. If you consider yourself an armchair detective, you’re in the right place, and you’re amongst friends. For the mystery-seeker, True Crime Garage presents an archive of missing persons, unsolved and cold cases, plus accounts of infamous serial killers and chilling solved cases. True Crime Garage has just one rule: don’t litter. Remember to not take yourself too seriously because if you do, nobody else will. Missing persons (including):Maura Murray Brandon Lawson Asha DegreeWiliam TyrellEmma FillipoffBrian ShafferJaliek Rainwalker Madeleine McCannJennifer KesseUnsolved cases (including):Mitrice Richardson Kendrick JohnsonJonBenet RamseyThe Delphi murdersOJ SimpsonThe Tylenol Murders Elisa LamThe Photo: Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon The West Memphis 3 Amy MihaljevicSerial killers (including):The Long Island Serial Killer (LISK)Zodiac Ted BundyThe Backpacker: Ivan Milat BTK: Dennis RaderJohn Wayne Gacy Jeffrey Dahmer Edmund KemperEd GeinSolved cases (including):Chris WattsThe Unabomber John Lennon Scott PetersonSon of SamColumbineRoom 309: Sidney Teerhuis-MoarKenneka JenkinsRae Carruth

Recent Episodes

Episodes loading...

Recent Reviews

Happygoddess

The whole story

I love this podcast because Nic & The Captain cover every true crime case extensively— no matter how many episodes it takes. It took me a little while to get used to the way they interact & tell about each case, but now I love this podcast!
BeeCuzThatsWhy

🤪

Hawking vibrators wasn’t on my garage bingo card….
Garrett Blashfield

Where’s Nick and captain?

Nov 19 episode, who are these guys talking in the opening. That is not the captain and the colonel. Even through the episode they sound different. WHAT HAVE YOU DONE WITH THEM
imacorcoran

One of the best

Thank you for not becoming a political podcast like all of the rest have! I love true crime garage, have listened for years and will continue to support!
Bschora

Big Love & a 1 Star Penalty

This is one of my favorite podcasts. It’s actually fun. Love the intros and outros the Captain composes. However, over the past year (2019/2020) the commercial time has gotten humongous. Three straight minutes a pop... so I’ve deducted one star. Seems they are adding one full minute of ads per break every season. Where will this end? Also The Captain seems to have gotten on an autotune bender — which hurts my ears. 2024. West Memphis 3, there’s an episode with a full THREE AND A HALF MINUTES OF ADVERTISEMENTS. Ouch. I’m dumbfounded by the WM3 episodes — lost on the order of things. Example, There’s 2 Part 2 of 2s. Are they redundant? Old or new? I’m lost. 2024, man, the ads are getting crazy. E767 I hit Fwd 12 times to by pass ads at 30-seconds a pop. That’s SIX minutes of ads because I can’t pay for a subscription. Whew! EPISODE 801, SIX MINUTES COMMERCIAL BREAK?!
doglover76754

Captain’s voice sounds so different tonight

We love him and hope he’s feeling okay! Love Nic too ❤️
karilove1980

Ads

Too many and too often. 5 star content and research however
thalizard

Synergy

The back and forth between these guys is so entertaining, can’t recommend this one enough.
Mikki595

BEST TRUE CRIME PODCAST OF ALL!!!

True Crime Garage is the best true crime podcast out there. Nic and The Captain do very thorough research and bring the crime to life so you hear everything that happened. They talk about the victims with such respect and compassion. The Captain is awesome at describing the suspect saying what we are all thinking. I have listened to every single episode and look daily for new content. They have become family. Love you guys!!! Subscribe and listen. If you thought you knew all about a case, I think you will learn something new. BEST TRUE CRIME PODCAST! ❤️🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤❤️
Shoopdawoop craziness is king

Always intelligent, sensitive, and entertaining!

As expected, your continued and most recent comprehensive coverage of the Delphi case is stellar! I am a listener from the start and read Nic’s book as soon as it came out, so I know what this case means to both of you. Thank you for being such informed and reasonable voices throughout this tragedy. Cheers!
TDTOOTZI

Here

What is the name of the beer?
Jeff Miller1

Some cases that need help

Ashley Heavyrunner Kimberly Bearclaw Iron Mary Katherine Miller Sage Smith Susan Smalley Stacie Madison
Shop Talk Podcast

My brother Nic

Nic Edwards is my brother not anymore. He’s a homophobic slur slinging piece of garage of a person. I can only wish the worst for you. I’m also pat’s brother also not a very nice person. Now all these negative self serving people are out of my life and my families lives, We as in my family can live a less drama hate filled lives. Now you’ve shown your true character. How do measure success? I live in a home not a house. My children will never be around you or your wives family. Including your wife’s ex-husband, how is he?
Professor Petticoat

Double Thumbs Up

Five stars coming at you from...you guessed it, Parts Unknown. Gotta hate the haters as you guys are the best. Love the deep dives, the conjecture, and of course, The Captains interjections and rants. Cheers with the Beers. Jessica
susannj

Dominque Dunne

John Thomas Sweeney is a liar and he basically got away with murder. This case infuriates me. What a terrible miscarriage of justice that he did not serve life in prison. White male privilege on parade. Ugh.
Mewhorter

Episodes 795 and 796

First off absolutely love you guys and all the work you put into these cases. Also have a ton of respect for all the research and efforts of Dr. Hewitt but I think he’s reaching with his “person of interest”. Again you guys are freaking awesome listen to every episode every week!!! O-H
Cherylb2021

Delphi case

True Crime Garage has always been one of my favorite crime podcasts. Both hosts speak intelligently and respectfully of the victims. Thorough and informative.
JD ER

True Crime Garage

My favorite podcast! Nic and the captain do a great job together of presenting the facts and also very insightful speculation in the world a true crime. Five out of five bottle caps! CHEERS
CFHayback

Good show, but…

The captain constantly shows what a hayseed he really is. Plus, he’s a closeted MAGA. Thinking man? No. Fool. Sucker. Still thinks Adnan *may* have done it. Uses, “I’m just asking questions.” years after that has proven to be a Q dog whistle.
CourtKJ4

The best!

Truly one of the best and most thorough true crime podcasts out there. They delve into so many different cases and provide a wealth of detail and knowledge. It takes a bit to get used to their pace and light banter, but I promise it’s worth it because you can’t really find a better duo. Appreciate this podcast so much. It’s the only one I make a priority to listen to every single week.
colburnorama

794

try to be more unbiased. Show some responsibility. I know you can't stand criticism: I appreciate you 99%
dhxhrjsjx

Lame

These guys are PC fruits. God forbid you insult some soft loser with your podcast 🤣 man up.
Jimmy Neutronic

Had to unfollow

Been there sense the beginning but the show just lags now. Energy. Pacing. Ads. Maybe it’s not the story telling. Maybe I’m just old. But listened to one Israel Keyes episode and realized something crazy about the show. They have no idea what they are talking about. Thinking back on it…they never did. My bad. Also they are apparently tied to LaDonna Humphrey.
MelDar23

Nerds

Love listening to you both! I’m a long time watcher of That Chapter on YouTube. I am enjoying this new podcast with the two of you! Keep up the great work! Much love from the (50🌲).
shut up kid ur adopted

Unsolved

Used to be a good show. Last 25 episodes are mainly unsolved murders or missing persons. Some are 2 parts so figure 2 hours of talking about an unsolved case from 25 yrs ago. Sorry captain but not interested.
KLou18

When the Intrusive Thoughts Win

I love Nic’s approach to telling the stories of the victims. . The Captain’s music is amazing. And I love when the Captain will sing a couple of words of a songs in response to something Nic says. It’s relatable. Much appreciated yall!
Andinelson

My go-to podcast

Been listening for 3 or 4 years and I have trouble sticking with anything but this is my ride or die. I like the stories they choose, the amount of info they provide, and their interactions with each other. Keep rocking it you guys!
cb2529

Best of the best

I listen to *many* true crime podcasts, and I’ve been tuning into TCG since 2016. It’s the best. These guys do SO MUCH research. Nic should be a detective, he thinks like one and because they have law enforcement in the family, they’re often able to get an inside perspective. The Captain has come a long way since the early days, and sprinkles in humor with his own views of the case (which often vary from Nic’s). Keep it up guys!
lissa309

Great coverage of lesser-known cases!

Thank you for your work and being so thorough! I use your pod in my research into potential victims of Israel Keyes and have found some interesting potentials i wouldn’t have otherwise (pastor Carol, Crystal Bradshaw, Boca Mall, and bc it reminds me of Lauren S… I will now deep dive Kyle F). Great work and down to earth guys who are actually doing good works, not just purporting to care about the people impacted by these crimes *ahem* like some others make a big show of for their own $ gain.
JannaB17

The best out there

Nic and the Captain are the perfect hosts for a true crime podcast. TCG is insightful and riveting. The analysis is thorough and unbiased. Once you start listening you can’t stop. Thank you!!!
PodcastListener-2020

The OG

Thoroughly researched.
Zombee Bob

Great Podcast, Doing Good

A thoroughly enjoyable, edifying podcast. The rapport between the hosts is fantastic. Many have said before, and I agree, that it really feels like you are in the garage, having a beer, and talking true crime with friends. They clearly do a great deal of research on each case, which often translates to learning a new detail about even cases Im already familiar with. What I truly appreciate about Nic and the Captain is their focus on and advocation for crime victims.
Kristina P 78

TCG is the best

TCG is the best true crime podcast. I have 4-5 favorites. But the guys will always be my favorite. I have heard all 1200+ episodes of TCG and also their extra Patreon episodes. I feel safe with these men. I adore you both. ❤️❤️❤️
Kadie Sterb

Amazing podcast, great hosts, factual information!

I’m a long time listener of true crime but just came across TCG in the past year or so, and it quickly rose to the top of my “favorite” list. The hosts are incredible - interesting and lighthearted at times but all the while maintaining a very respectful tone of the victim’s stories. The podcast format is well laid-out and easy to follow along, with plenty of facts and none of the excess. Thanks, Nick and Captain for all you do!!!! Keep them coming!
nitrotitan2008

Start using victims name

Stop saying “the girl”, “this girl”. Just say her name. Sounds so demeaning. Nick is a know it all.
Caffeine Temptress

Good show

Hi, I’ve been listening to several different serial killer podcast now, and this is one of the best. I like NICK and the captain and I like the way they tell a story. They have a little bit of humor, but not too much. They stick to the facts and stick to the story. They don’t go off on tangents unlike another podcast, I could mention here, but won’t. Also, they they both have very good voices, which I think is an underrated quality to have when you are recording a podcast. Their voices are not raspy or squeaky, they are very pleasant to listen to. They do their research, and if they don’t know something, they admit it. all in all, a very good podcast!
POE1990

I appreciate your thoughtful analysis

Thank you for providing excellent reporting and thoughtful and well reasoned analysis. Some humor too. I miss your reporting on the terribly sad Abigail and Liberty murders. When I listen to the Murder Sheet, I think of True Crime Garage.
ellum enopie

Nice

I love
eschroe3

Pretty good except one episode was rough

I think you guys are awesome and do a great job but I never thought of leaving a review until I heard the columbine episode. The captain sounded like he was drunk out of his mind and couldn’t retain a thought. If I could just rate one episode I would cause that was rough to listen to.
Sulynsic

Best of the Best!

This is the cream that rises to the top of true crime podcasts!
TabethaMemmel

Thank you

I’ve been listening to you guys for years!!!! Love it
kathieray

Wow!

I have been listening forever and have even listened to all of your back episodes and love them all. I have never reviewed you! True crime lovers this podcast is factual, clear to the point, not a lot of wandering off topic and great to listen to. The music mixes are an added bonus. Worth a listen to! I love them!!!
Koralakers

Very thorough and informative

Many other True Crime podcasts talk forever, ad nauseam, just to hear themselves talk. These guys give a complete view focusing on facts, and not just their opinions. Super down to earth guys. Easy to listen to. Almost calming.
rafaelash

The best

This is my favorite true crime poddy. I like how they explore different sides of the story, reports etc, and add their 2 cents. Adds more depth to the stories they cover
Gunslinger Bee

Solid show - just one thing…

Love the show! The level of detail is fantastic. One thing - it’s super uncomfortable every time The Captain makes a joke and Nic just rolls by and ignores it. Please Nic, “yes and” your friend! Sure it’s Dad humor but it’s less groan inducing if you bounce off him a bit. Tall cans in the air for Dad humorists 🫶
Dlayden

Favorite

By far my favorite podcast. They present the story and the facts and provide excellent details and insight. Couldn’t ask for more. I’ll be sad when I run out of episodes to run to or they decide to hang it up!
Cindy13❤️

Great show

This podcast is the one that got me hooked on listening to podcasts. Great podcast. Keep turning out your show please. Thank you for your hard work
Karen now Kitty

I agree

I just heard Nicks rant about privacy. It was masterful. It’s why I love the garage. I’ve listened since episode 10. Silicon Valley has made billions of profits and spy on us. When we want info they cite privacy. Where’s my privacy when they track me using maps and search. I like the cut of that jib. Way to go.
R-WTG

The TC Show that got me started in true crime!

I have been listening for years and really enjoy the analytical way the boys discuss the cases. Love how I know something good is coming when the Crispy Colonel says, “Hey, listen,”. I know a truth bomb is coming!
pcay 1

Great podcast

You should check out farmers brewing co. In Princeton ca. they have great beer!!! Love your podcast been listening to it for a couple years

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.