Great Yankee insight, horrible political commentary

A salute to both of you! Objective Yankees criticism is unmatched. Again, thank you. J. L. Urquhart Boise, Idaho

Favorite of all the yankee fan podcasts. It feels like I’m listening to 2 true fans who have no other interests other than the Yankees winning it all.

Love JJ & Nick. Very lighthearted & funny. Much different from the Bronx Pinstripes Show. Maybe 1 day I’ll see JJ & Nick at the parade.

Dumb

Let’s talk Yankee baseball not how can I buy suite Boring

Love the passion these guys bring!

Great podcast can’t wait for it to keep growing

Don’t wast your time listening. JJ is an awful host who cares more about getting rises on Twitter and smoking joints. Stick to Bronx Pinstripes and Talkin Yanks for you Yankee podcast.

I’ve been a loyal Bronx Pinstripes listener for years and I wasn’t as impressed with the first year of George’s Box, but the new combo of JJ and Nick is perfect. They encompass all the hope, love, hate, and discontent of real Yankee fans. I’m all in on George’s Box!

Love the pod. I’ve never related to two guys more as a yankee fan in my life than when it comes to JJ and Nick. Guys know how to get me ready to run through a wall at 9 am

One of the best podcast! 🙏🏽

JJ and Nick have such an awesome dynamic! Kirby knows more about the Yankees than anyone I know and is always on top of the game. Excited to listen every time

My guy birdman knows how to spin a yarn. Sit back and enjoy

You can tell these guys are huge Yankees fans. They keep up with everything and provide funny takes on some of the players.

They bring the Bronx personality to a podcast. Really enjoy this duo!

JJ & Nick seem like the type you would like to meet at a bar and talk Yankee baseball with. I end up laughing at something they say each podcast. Definitely a great listen and would recommend to any Yankee fan. See you at the parade!

JJ is the greatest Yankees podcast host in the WWOOOOOOORRRRRRLLLLLLDDDDDDD. I love the passion here between nick and jj for the Yankees. These two make you wanna come back for more and the intro makes me wanna run through a wall. Can’t wait for the parade

The MLB might be affraid of corona virus , but JJ and Nick sure aren't. Helping me fill the void of a baseball less world with 5 star analysis and 4.5 star humor.

Love the give and take from these two! Lots of great analysis. Love the addition of Kirby, his passion for Yanks baseball is unmatched

JJ and Nick combo has been great this season. Perfect balance between them, covering all the important Yankees topics of the week. See you both at the parade!

All real Yankees fans do!!!

I enjoy this addition to The Bronx Pinstripes world. JJ brings a great take to the Yankees. He loves his Yankee baseball and will definitely drop some knowledge. I am interested to see what Nick Kirby brings to the pod!

I was so excited to listen to this podcast since I’m a regular listener of the Bronx Pinstripes podcast. The first chance I had to listen the hosts didn't talk Yankees for at least the first 15 minutes. I say that since I shut it off. I couldn’t handle any more. First they talked bad about religion then talked about how great mushroom drugs were. What the heck. Just an awful podcast.

First off, some technical problems, the last few episodes have been abnormally quite and volume has to go way up to even hear it. When you are working in a medium where your only delivery is Sound, get the sound right. Finally... JJ is an awful person, and is milking this dog story for all its worth now that Keith, the only positive part of the podcast, is gone.

When you interview someone, they’re the ones who are supposed to do the talking. You did all the talking with Karen, the Yankee fan, church woman. You talked about yourself endlessly. So self-centered. I won’t be listening again.

I get goosebumps every time I hear the intro. JJ has a lot of passion about baseball and life. Not your typical Yankee podcast

JJ has the same passion as I do for the Yankees so 5 star all the way! As a real yankee fan unlike most of the uninformed generic yankee fan and a season ticket holder i never thought I’d find a personality who could match my fandom.

Great podcast...Ebony/Ivory, Rocky/Apollo, Skip/Stephen, Keith/JJ....confrontation and diversity is great in entertainment. JJ’s sometimes Adversarial Sports Knowledge approach VS Keith’s Millennial Party Boy were complimentary and made me say each week ‘what are they gonna say this time?’....edge of seat hilarity. A loss in my opinion. No insult to Andrew at all as he’s the Yang to Scott’s Ying... I ABSOLUTELY wish Keith ALL THE BEST....

I met JJ at a Bronx Pinstripes event. But I did not listen to his podcast because I wasn’t a fan of his partner. Let me say that JJ is quite enough of a draw on his own. Happy to hear Andrew as first co host guest. (Especially since the fun pokes) Looking forward to the podcast now. You need to listen!

JJ and Keith are a blast to listen to. They provide great Yankees content and a banter that you’d overhear in any seat at Yankees stadium or bar. Love the intense passion these guys have for the Bombers!

The best Yankee Podcast out there. Love both of you guys and the energy you guys bring day in and day out. I’ve been listening since the beginning and this podcast deserves like 15 stars but it only allows me to give me 5.

This is the BEST Yankees podcast! JJ and Keith are very informative about what’s going on with the Yankees and they’re hilarious! JJ is “the type of Yankees fan that no one likes” and Keith is the “lovable Yankees fan” which makes for a great podcast duo and a very entertaining and funny show!😂 If you like the Yankees then this podcast is for you!

Very informative and funny, my favorite podcast yet! You guys stay within context and always make sure to point out good facts about the team and players etc.... Go Yankees! #replacefor28!

These guys are the best. This is my new favorite podcast. Can’t wait for the new one each week. JJ and Keith are both informative and hilarious the way they present each week. Trust me. You will not be disappointed!

Best pod in the biz

Great Yankees podcast bringing hot takes and fresh content. Keith and JJ keep it real. JJ could be a bit of a moron, but Keith more than makes up for it with his nonstop, fast-paced life.

Great entertaining podcast that covers everything Yankee baseball and more throughout the league. Definitely worth it to subscribe I listen to just about every episode and always enjoy them. Easily the most exciting Yankees podcast in the world.

Right from the start it’s cringe after cringe. No one is as unproportionally smug as jj. So much smug. Such a terrible unfunny person. Sounds frosty too.

Unfortunately relocated to Raleigh NC a year ago and miss home (Yankee Stadium). Listening to these guys is like getting caught up with your boys at a bar. 90% Yankees / 10% pure exceptional nonsense. Strip club buffet so far ranks as my favorite moment of nonsense. Even if you’re not a yankee fan, these guys are still entertaining to listen to. Keep up the good work.

JJ & Keith do an amazing job breaking down the Yankees! They are great people too and cannot be more awesome dudes! Follow and subscribe if you are a Yankee fan!

To the BP Crew for providing another solid Yankees podcast. Sign up to both BP podcasts and get a taste of the most flavorfully diverse set of personalities. You have the brains, the brawn, the mouth and the OG baseball guy. You figure out who is who. Not only do they bring you eclectic content but they are on multiple platforms to keep you engaged. Don’t miss out and sign up now!

They cover absolutely everything expected and everything you didn't expect...must listen!

This is the most exciting podcast IN THE WOOOORLD 😂 haha it is sooo gooood that it actually makes me sad that we have only one episode a week. Good job guys #BPCrew

Only thing I don’t like about the show is it’s only once a week! Great job Keith and JJ!!! Please at least give us 2 days a week!

I listen every week but prefer Scott and Andy from the Bronx pinstripes show. JJ is funny but he and Keith can be a bit harsh sometimes with almost yelling into the mic and constant cursing and trash talking about other teams. I understand the Sox but why the need to tell every met fan that they’re f@“*ing idiots when they’re not doing well and don’t affect the yanks at all? Agreed with other commenters, keith is usually a stereotypical fan that makes people hate us yankee fans. Overall a good and entertaining show, just a bit too much sometimes.

“This is my favorite show...because it is my show” - Tom Green Sincerely, Keith McPherson #ReplaceFor28

JJ is the reason I keep listening to the show. Dudes hilarious and at the same time has a great amount of knowledge of the Yankees. Keith has a solid personality, but you can tell he’s just one of those generic and stereotypical Yankee fans. Gotta give him credit for coming up with #ReplaceFor28 though

Good show, a little too focused on twitter and social media and not on the Yankees.

Love the podcast! As a Chatham resident, especially love all of the Chatham A references!