I used to really enjoy the show, but ever since Tony got hired in AEW, they spend more time talking about that than what they’re watching.

I love this show and have listened since the start but it just doesn’t feel fun like it used to be. Tony shoots everything fun down. Conrad has to beg and plead to get Tony to speak more than 20 words in a 1 hour show even when it’s about helping promote AEW. I really hope Tony still has fun doing the show and isn’t just forcing himself to do the show at this point just because he feels like he has to. At this point it feels like the latter. Although, ultimately my opinion doesn’t matter, it’s just my perspective as a long time listener.

If Conrad’s other podcasts are too sophisticated for you, try this one. These 2 seem to have mastered crassness and vulgarity. If you’ve never surpassed Freud’s psychosexual anal stage, this podcast will also be of much delight to you. I’d much rather listen to Jeff Jarrett than Tony. He at least sounds like a decent person.

Your rant about guys who like cats killed my interest in this show

Any true old school wrestling fan will enjoy this podcast, for both the nostalgia and for Tony’s old school take on today’s product. Dude has grown and evolved with the business, which means there’s hope for all of us lapsed fans as well. Maybe it’s not for everyone, but it’s been a favorite for me since day one. If you say it’s never made you laugh, “you a lie”. Keep up the great work guys!

One of the true joys in life is when Conrad gets Tony all worked up lol.

First couple years are gold

If having your dog die is “the hardest thing you’ve ever had to deal with in your life”, you’ve had an AMAZINGLY fortunate life. You managed to go to work…..after your DOG died? Truly the bravest among us! “Dogs are the most amazing thing on earth!?” I mean…..what’s the second most amazing thing?…pop tarts!? Bear in mind, these are the melancholy musings of a GROWN….MAN…..Yikes.

Great show, but it’s been missing my three favorite words in the English language; “Tony Reads Rap”. Tony, you GOTTA bring that back. The people DEMAND Tony Reads Rap!

The episode with Dylan Postl was very enjoyable. But nothing can make up for that stinker of an episode that the Orange Cassidy one was. I didn’t take him for a guy who hosted such a pity party.

Been listening from the start always amazing. Great time with Conrad and Tony!

The content is garbage the production is trash. The show is a lot of dead air and meaningless juvenile humor.

Great for nostalgia and big laughs!

Conrad is the biggest mark and clown there is the patriot was right yea you might be good at selling mortgages but people only know you cuz who u married to he made money in wrestling u make money off of wrestling it’s a difference your jokes aren’t funny you don’t have no stories you not the star stop kemp talking bout what people couldn’t do in wrestling when u are the most unathletic person you go round buying belts to feel like a athlete foh

I feel like it’s now AEW plugs non stop, and I watch AEW. It seems like the first 20 minutes is how AEW is so great. It went from What Happened When to let’s put over AEW.

Tony

I look forward to this show every week. I’ve considered subscribing to the Patreon- however I haven’t just yet, because I need Tony reads rap back. Tony reads tweets? Tony reads comments on female wrestler photos. I mean c’mon! Give us something, Tony!

Finally a podcast that doesn’t take itself too seriously. A lot of fun and a lot of memories of wrestling years gone by.

Please, it’s the highlight of y week

Tony Shiovone is the armpit of the wrestling bussiness. Everything he’s been on makes it feel less than it is, WCW and AEW. You can see why he never made it to the big leagues

That’s exactly right JR! WHW is the absolute best. Tony and Conrad make my day with this podcast. Yeah that ol’ Kentucky waterfall sporting, CZ wearing, Tommy Bahama rocking, Bug loving, MJF hating, voice of our childhood is still the best in the business. Thank you Tony and Conrad for all you do for us fans. Now let’s go to the ring, where Lois has just TOPE SUICIA’d into a pile of dog hair looking for Conrad’s 6 man belt, and didn’t spill her drink. We’re desperately out of time!

This show that gets me through my work week. Tony is hilarious and helps to bring back memories from my childhood, both good and bad. I think we need a little more Tony reads rap for sure.

I have listened to What Happened When since the podcast began, and it is my favorite wrestling podcast to listen to. Listening to Conrad and Tony is one of the best parts of my week. This podcast brings me a lot of joy, and I encourage any wrestling fan to give it a try. They will have you in tears from laughing, and you won't want to miss an episode.

My favorite of Conrad’s family of pods. I enjoy the goofy back and forth of crazy stuff like D hair wishes lol. Plus Tony is a grumpy dude and fed up with the clownery of 2022, like myself. Great listen and lots of fun.

I work in a restaraunt as a soux chef. None of the other kitchen staff were really big into wrestling and now they are! We all love the podcasts keep on keepin on! - leroux crew

TOMMY YOUNG!!!! Don’t ever change Tony, love the podcast and all that you do to entertain us. Even if you are from West Virginia.

WHW with Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson is by far the best podcast Conrad is a part of. From the pilot to the latest episode, Tony’s journey has been an interesting one, from dipping his toe back in the water of the professional wrestling world, to commentating again on TBS and TNT. Sure Tony forgot a few things from back in the day, but it doesn’t take away from his charm. This show has really gotten me through some difficult times, between Covid shutting down everything and the uncertainties for the future, to me losing both my mother and father within a year and a half of each other, WHW helped me laugh and give me a distraction in the toughest times of my life. Tony and Conrad teach all of us that life is too short to take things so seriously. Thank you gentlemen.

Tony and Conrad bring you weekly laughs. Yes they do great watch alongs however their show is so much more. You are invited in to watch wrestling with two friends who then tell hysterical stories about people in their lives. They need a WHW2 of baloney Jim and others. I find myself laughing so much I have to rewind to hear what I miss. Many times the tape machines start rolling and you are surprised how much time has flown by. It’s a great when you and ink in two hours weekly you know are going to be fun.

What Happened When has been my favorite podcast for years. Tony and Conrad have me crying from laughing so hard more often than not. It’s the perfect way to not think about the real world, and be entertained for a couple of hours! WHW Fan 4 Life!!!

The show is the funniest podcast out there! It’s a must listen!

Thank you guys, have no idea what I’d be listening to all day at work without the podcast. Much love from Arizona*edit 11/02/22* For a while this was the only AFS pod that wasnt going through the motions but today Tony openly said he’d no longer be critical of anything that wasnt WWE, looks like 83 weeks is the last man standing.

I love this podcast!! Tony is so funny and he doesn’t even try 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Conrad get “I’ve outgrown kooter” on a t shirt and I’m buying 😭

Dumb!!

Great podcast but it’s nothing but ads & tracking now.

Tony has very little to add to the story of any of these shows. It’s just two guys talking randomly. It can be funny at times but it’s certainly not entertaining

Love Tony, love Conrad, love that this is the one podcast I don’t need to worry about Paul B ever hosting (Paul = channel changer jones)

RULZ!

Listening to this podcast takes me back to the days when my father and I would watch WCW. We hated the N.W.O., loved Sting, and spent many Monday nights together while my mother said, “I wish y’all wouldn’t watch that stuff.” Now my Dad has cancer and is going through treatments. I listen to the podcast and think back to those memories I made with my dad. We are hoping the treatments work, but if they don’t, it is awesome to have a voice that brings back those great memories.

Tony and Conrad are great when doing watch alongs. Loved the year of Crockett.

That title may be a bit much, but awesome show. Tony was the voice of my childhood and Conrad is the voice of my 40s. Thanks fellas.

4, 4, FOUR ad spots in the first 21 minutes. No longer listenable. Even Tony sounds uninterested in the show because of the ads. No thanks, best of luck Tony, when this dries up, find someone who isn’t trying to use your name for ad revenue.

At least when they did PPV watch along before they would watch the entire show now it’s just 2 matches? Let me guess the rest of it will be on ad free shows that you need to pay for

I’m still giving this a 5 stars but get ready to work that skip button! The ads are getting painful! How much money does one need to make? Especially all the ads free podcast barking! I’ve left many of Conrad’s podcasts because they’ve become filthy with ads. I’m thinking I’ll be dropping WHW for the same reason soon.

Every 3 minutes. I get it, ad free shows. But seriously lol.

Conrad and Tony together is the most fun that I have with audio on a regular basis.

This podcast is terrible. It used to be good but it is now 1.5 hours of commercials. I gave up on it.

If you grew up in the 80’s and loved JCP, then this podcast is for you! The watch-along format is awesome and the commentary, promos, and action are all top quality. Conrad is a great host and does a great job of leading the show. Tony is an all-timer and offers such a unique perspective to the wrestling business. I made the show 4-stars because the ADS are getting a bit much. For the most recent show (Nov 2), there were 20 minutes of ads in the first 25 minutes of the show. Yikes!

I fast forward forty five minutes at least to get past the boring banter to get to the 86 content. Once the show starts it’s great, but the pre show banter is terrible.

This show is awesome love hearing the stories of the wrestling past going back to the 80s and 90s

Tbh, I don’t really care for the new 1986 format, it’s a lil too far back for me. Some of the old Dusty, Flair, and AA stuff is cool, but that’s about it. But I still LOVE Conrad and Tony’s banter!!!